Category Archives: Media

Openness & Honesty – Asylum Seekers & Refugee Project Experiences

This semester, the third year journalism students at the University of Canberra have been part of a project called “Reporting Refugees“. This project has seen the UC students collaborate with local organisations like Canberra Refugee Support and Companion House to report asylum seekers/refugee stories in the Canberra region.

As a third year journalism student I took part in this project. Going in to the project I knew little about asylum seekers/refugees. But as the project progressed I learned a lot about what it means to be an asylum seeker/refugee and what challenges they face. I have grown to respect these people. Most of them have experienced some terrifying things back in their home country. When you hear their stories it’s like a movie to us in the Western world. Their stories seem so unreal. Too dreadful to be real.

The project has made me think more about the needs of refugees and asylum seekers, and how we treat them when they come to our country. We should treat them with respect and not let them rot in detention centres. We need to process their applications faster and take responsibility. Sending these people to East Timor is not taking responsibility in my eyes.

When reporting on asylum seekers/refugees you, as a journalist, need to think about what consequences your story might have for your sources and their families. Being portrayed in the media might be highly dangerous for these people and their families. So it’s really important that you tell them about these risks because they might not think about it themselves.

PRIOR PERSPECTIVES
Prior to commencing work on this project I had never thought about if I have had any contact with asylum seekers or refugees. I may have had contact with such a person without knowing about it. However, when we started this project I didn’t even know the difference between an asylum seeker and a refugee.

My attitude towards asylum seekers/refugees was that every human being is worth the same. If someone is forced to leave their country, or they are in danger, they should be able to get help. In my eyes Australia has an obligation to help these people. Asylum seekers and refugees have rights like every other human being.

Australia has obligations to protect the human rights of all asylum seekers and refugees who arrive in Australia, regardless of how or where they arrive and whether they arrive with or without a visa (Australian Human Rights Commission 2011).

I understand that Australia cannot help all the refugees and asylum seekers in the world. But it is important to me that the once arriving in Australia, they have the right to be treated as human beings. Lately, there have been quite a few riots among asylum seekers at different detention centres in Australia. These happenings make me wonder if these people are treated right. We cannot just treat them as another problem, which we can push onto an island (Christmas Island) and it’s gone. It doesn’t work that way.

ON ASSIGNMENT FOR #REPORTINGREFUGEES

During this project I have learned what the difference is between an asylum seeker and a refugee.

The 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (and its 1967 Protocol), to which Australia is a signatory, defines a refugee as:

Any person who owing to a well founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his/her nationality and is unable, or owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself/herself of the protection of that country.

An asylum seeker is a person who is seeking protection as a refugee and is still waiting to have his/her claim assessed (Refugee council of Australia 2011).

In my opinion some refugees are very open and happy to talk about their past, while others just “shut the door” and don’t want to talk about their past. Humans deal with things differently. Some like to talk about their experiences although they might have been terrible, while others want to keep their story to themselves.

In Canberra there are a few very friendly and open Sudanese refugees. I feel blessed that we found the Dinka congregation at the St. George’s Anglican Church in Pearce. These people were happy to talk to us about their congregation and community. Some of them even told us about their life back in Sudan and how they came to Australia. They were a lovely community and I’m sure I’ll go back and visit them in the future.

The project has strengthened my views about how asylum seekers and refugees should be treated. Knowing a few refugees, this is not just a word to me anymore. When I hear the word REFUGEE mentioned, I think about the people I talked to during this project and I can see their faces.

If all Australians had the chance to sit down and talk to an asylum seeker or a refugee, I think that would change a lot of Aussies’ opinions on asylum seeker/refugee issues. They would see that most of these people want to learn English and contribute to the Australian society. They are not in Australia to go on unemployment benefits. They are here because they are not safe in their own country.

This project has made me think about what the Australian Government does in relation to asylum seekers/refugees, and the policies in place. I don’t believe that the Australian Government’s plan to establish a processing centre for asylum seekers in East Timor is a good idea. To be honest, I feel like the government is trying to disclaim responsibility for the situation, instead of seeking real regional solutions to the problem.

“If the Government is serious about stopping the movements of asylum seekers who come to Australia by boat, it must put significant thought, effort and investment into developing a refugee protection framework across the Asia Pacific region, rather than seeking to outsource its commitments and warehouse asylum seekers in East Timor,” said Dr Graham Thom, Refugee Coordinator for Amnesty International Australia (Amnesty International 2011).

LESSONS FROM THE FIELD

The project has taught me, when reporting asylum seeker/refugee issues you have to think about what the consequences might be for the people you talk to. These people do not always think about how dangerous it can be for them to talk to the media. Sometimes it is your job as a journalist, to remind them of the risk involved. Although, the people you speak to are in a safe country at the time of the interview, their family back in their home country may be in danger.

People fleeing persecution leave families behind who may face retribution from repressive regimes if relatives in the UK [ or other countries] are identified (Media Wise 2008).

This might be scary to think about as a journalist. But it is important that you do think about it because of the severe consequences your actions might have for other people. When I was out in the field during this project, I always asked my talents if it was safe for them to talk to me. I didn’t push anyone to talk to me. The people I spoke to were happy to talk to me about their life here in Australia and some also talked about their life back in Sudan.

However, one of my talents was happy to talk to me at the time of the interview, and he signed a consent form. But a few weeks later he contacted me and said that he didn’t want to be in a video that was going to be published on the ABC website. Apparently, he had talked to his mother who found it scary, and didn’t like the idea of him being in a video. So it was a challenge for me and my partner how to handle this. We had already finalized the video at that stage and sent it off to the ABC.

Next time I’m assigned an asylum seeker/refugee story I will have better knowledge how to report on asylum seeker/refugee issues. For an Australian journalist it’s good to try to follow the MEAA Code of Ethics, which says that a journalist should commit himself/herself to:

  • honesty
  • fairness
  • independence
  • respect for the rights of others

In addition to the Code of Ethics, you ought to follow the advice in Media Wise’s Reporting Asylum and Refugee Issues.  Here you can find guidelines and tips for how to report on these kinds of issues.

There is a lot to think about when reporting on asylum seekers/refugees, but as long as you are open and honest with them you can get some very interesting stories.

In my experience you have to think about what you write and who you are speaking with. It is always nice to have a good story, but some stories are too good to be true.

Sources:

Amnesty International, Amnesty International: Australia’s refugee policy going backwards fast, viewed 04 November 2011, http://www.amnesty.org.au/news/comments/24815/

Australian Human Rights Commission, viewed 02 November 2011, http://www.hreoc.gov.au/human_rights/immigration/asylum_seekers.html

Media, Entertainment & Art Alliance, Code of Ethics, viewed 04 November 2011, http://www.alliance.org.au/code-of-ethics.html

Media Wise, Reporting Asylum and Refugee Issues, viewed 04 November 2011, http://www.mediawise.org.uk/www.mediawise.org.uk/files/uploaded/ReportingAsylumleaflet2008.pdf

Refugee council of Australia, Background Information on Refugees & Asylum Seekers, viewed 02 November 2011, http://www.refugeecouncil.org.au/docs/news&events/RW_Background_Information.pdf

2 Comments

Filed under Media, Reporting Refugees, Uni

Academic Blog – My experiences in the Twittersphere

I started tweeting around a year ago with the handle @linn_87. When I started out, I had no idea how I should use Twitter. So my first tweets didn’t contain any links what so ever.

In recent months I have learnt how important it is to link to you sources in your tweets. Links make your tweets more credible because you’re telling your followers were you found the information. You’re not just putting information out there without any attribution.

As a journalism student I know how important it is to attribute information to a source. But when I first started using Twitter a year ago I didn’t know how to shorten links. This meant that a lot of the links I wanted to use where too long to fit into 140 characters, which is the character limit on Twitter.

When you know where to find and how to use a URL shortener it becomes a lot easier to use links in your tweets. My favourite URL shortener is bit.ly. Manly because you can see how many of your followers have clicked on your links. But you need to sign up to be able to see these statistics.

It can be an advantage to have access to these statistics because it tells you what your followers are interested in. Your followers will most likely only click on links that interest them. So these statistics can help you cater for your followers/audience.

You can cater for your audience by linking to information you know they will find useful or you can engage them in conversation. It’s up to you how you want to attract followers and keep them interested. But one thing you should keep in mind is that “conversational messages have more potential to engage audiences” (2011).

I think I still have a way to go when it comes to engaging my audience. In my eyes Annabel Crabb and Mark Colvin are very good at engaging their audience and they are an inspiration for me. I want to become just as good as they are at engaging my audience.

It is important for a aspiring journalist to follow well-established journalists on Twitter and see how they use the medium. Julie Posetti found in her research that “professional journalists are using Twitter to enhance and augment traditional reporting practices. Many journalists…are now logged onto Twitter throughout their working day” (2009).

ABC radio producer Andrew Davies told Julie Posettie that he tries to start his day by looking at what people are saying and talking about on Twitter. He said, “I love to read all the fantastic links to interesting websites, ideas (and) news that people have sent out” (2009). This stresses the importance of linking.

As ABC’s Managing Director Mark Scott wrote, “one of the things Twitter is most useful for is linking. In fact, 25 per cent of all Tweets contain links” (2010).

Reporters Julie Posetti interviewed are using Twitter “to ‘broadcast’ links to content they or their news outlet have produced in an effort to build a new audience” (2009). I have also published links to my own work on Twitter to try and build my readership. But with only 90 followers this is not easy.

By building up followers on Twitter you are building your readership. You can get people to follow you by commenting on their tweets, message them directly or live report events that other people find interesting.

On the 23th of April I went to an ice hockey game between Canberra Knights and Newcastle North Stars. I decided to live tweet the game and after the game I had three more followers. This was an eye opening experience for me and showed me how easy it can be to build your audience.

Twitter has given us the opportunity to report on an event as it unfolds. Good examples of real time reporting are the Christchurch earthquake, the disaster in Japan and the death of Osama bin Laden. I read about all of these events on Twitter before I heard about them in the mainstream media.

So Twitter allows the public to break news, but how do you know that what you read on Twitter is true? Rory O’Conner has written about the dangers of social media and unfiltered information.

“This unparalleled information access, although empowering, is also disruptive and presents its own unique set of issues and challenges, both to journalists and to society as a whole.”

He says that the audience can’t know for sure what is true and what is false when they are dealing with “unfiltered” information. And in an environment as Twitter faulty information can spread very quickly (2009, p.4).

Journalist Harley Dennett told Julie Posetti that the public is less likely to trust news broken on Twitter than news delivered by traditional media outlets.

“Sometimes people don’t believe me when I reveal something on Twitter before the full story, with supporting quotes and documentation, comes out in print or online. It’s hard to prove something in 140 characters when there’s nothing to link.”

As Julie Posetti says journalists should “exercise caution” and do proper research before publishing something they have seen on Twitter. It is very easy to set up a fake Twitter account and start publishing tweets (2009).

Journalists are constantly under pressure to produce stories and publish information. Sometimes it can be hard to verify tweets. Here is a link to a guide with 6 easy ways to verify tweets.

As a journalist you have to find a balance between accuracy, speed and depth. In the Twittersphere speed seems to be the most important, which concerns me. I don’t want social media to lower the quality of journalism.

But in some instances speed is the most important criteria. If an event is unfolding speed is essential and Twitter is a great tool to get information out to the public. As Roy Peter Clark writes, tweets can give the public snapshots from an “unravelling narrative”.

He says that while newspapers have moved away from mini-narratives, Tweeters can be very creative with the way they deliver news.

“A live blog is a kind of serial narrative constructed in real time, and Facebook and Twitter often resemble the grammar and style of direct, observed reporting (2011).”

Although, Twitter is a great tool for real time reporting there are obvious pitfalls. One of which are addiction. Watch this  YouTube video as an example.

Another pitfall is the amount of information you get on Twitter. Although it’s a lot of good information out there, how can you find THE GOOD information among all the other useless information? My answer to this question is, start using lists. By dividing the accounts you follow into lists, you organize the information, and it’s much easier to navigate your Twitter account.

Although, Twitter has some downsides it’s a revolutionary journalism tool. It is an important tool in broadcast journalism. If you watch Q and A on the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) on Mondays you know that they are broadcasting tweets from the public. This is one of the ways you can use Twitter as a broadcaster, to get instant viewer feedback.

In most cases instant viewer feedback is a good thing. But when a staff member at the TV channel who is airing the tweets has to make them up because of too few responses, it is not a good thing. Priscilla Jebaraj reported that this happened at the Indian channel IBN in December 2010.

So as a broadcaster it’s important to be honest with your audience and only use tweets generated by the viewers. If not, I don’t see the point in using instant viewer feedback. It’s supposed to be a way for the viewers to interact in real-time and get their say.

Nevertheless, I think for the most part broadcasters are honest and are using Twitter in a legitimate way. When used in the right way Twitter is a great journalism tool. It has already changed and are changing journalism practises. So get on board and try it out because Twitter is here to stay.

References:

Clark, RP 2011, How journalists are using Facebook, Twitter to write mini serial narratives, Poynter, viewed 13 May 2011.

Jebaraj, P 2010, Fake tweets aired on TV news show, The Hindu, viewed 14 May 2011.

O’Conner, R 2009, Word of Mouse: Credibility, Journalism and Emerging Social Media, Joan Shorenstein Centre on the Press, Politics and Public Policy, viewed 13 May 2011.

Posetti, J 2009, How Journalists Are Using Twitter in Australia, PBS Mediashift, viewed 12 May 2011.

Scott, M 2010, The Golden Age for Australian journalism, ABC The Drum, viewed 12 May 2011.

Studies find journalists use Twitter for broadcast 2011, Reportr, viewed 12 May 2011.


3 Comments

Filed under Media, Uni

Online News – Twitter

Creator Rosaura Ochoa

I believe it’s important for aspiring journalists to have a Twitter account. But you can’t just have an account you need to know how to use Twitter. You need to engage with your followers and you have to decide what kind of profile you want to build.

Yeah, Twitter is a good place for building your brand as a journalist. However, you need to decide how much of your private life you want to share with your followers. Some journalists share more of their private life than others.

Journalists who share private things with their followers think this makes them more human, and it’s easier for their followers to connect with them. I believe this is true but I still think it’s a question of how much you should share.

Here is a funny YouTube video about Twitter.

Now I will look at a few journalist profiles on Twitter.

Starting with Mark Colvin’s profile, who calls himself Colvinius. Mark tweets a lot, and as well as tweeting himself he retweets quite a lot. He regularly engages in conversations with his followers. I feel his Twitter account is really professional and he doesn’t tweet much about his private life.

Next up is Annabel Crabb, who is annabelcrabb on Twitter. She engage with her followers in conversation and she use humour when tweeting. She also arranges meetings with sources of stories on Twitter as well as promoting her own work. She does this by telling her followers what she is working on and when the story is finished she tweet a link to it. I think this is a good way of doing it.

1 Comment

Filed under Media, Uni

Online News – Analysing slideshows

I don’t like this slideshow. The pictures aren’t good enough. There are a few good pictures in there but overall the pitures are bad.

He mixes colour and black & white pictures. That looks corny and it don’t work for me at all. Most of the time, it works best if you stick to either colour or black & white. As a rule, don’t mix the two.

The audio quality is also pretty bad. I can’t believe I actually watched the whole thing. I think that was only because I was looking for examples of bad slideshows.

To be honest, I don’t really have much positive feedback for this guy. Better luck next time, dude.

I like this slideshow. Most of the pictures match the audio. So although some of the pictures are pretty average, it don’t matter that much. She is telling a story about her family and the average picture quality just made it more real.

If I was her I would have replaced some of the pictures, especially, the once were you only see the back of people. Although this doesn’t face me too much I think it would be better if we saw their faces. Faces can tell you a lot.

Now, over to the audio. I think the audio was pretty average but then again this made it more real.

The length of the slideshow was good. Not too long. I think a slideshow should be around 3 minutes. If they are much longer than 3 minutes they have a tendency of getting a bit boring. So this is definitely something to think about when we are making our own slideshows.

2 Comments

Filed under Media, Opinion, Uni

Online News – Moderating Comments

Quite a few journalists coming straight out of University will find themselves in a job where they have to moderate comments for a media outlet. This is a very important job, although, it may not be what you have dreamt of during your years at University. Remember, you have to start somewhere.

Creator Gustavo Pimenta

Online media outlets have different rules and regulationg for what comments they allow on their websites. Some websites have a very spesified comment policy, like the Huffington Post.

The good thing with the Huffington Post comment policy is that it’s easy to find at the bottom of the page. This makes it easy for readers, who want to comment on a particular story, to find out what the website allows in terms of comments.

You can find the ABC comment policy under the link down the bottom of their website under ‘Conditions of use‘. Their comment policy is pretty strict.

But are they able to enforce their policy? If you look at comments under ‘The Drum‘ you can sometimes find comments that I think never should have been posted. This probably has to do with the restricted time The Drum crew can spend on comment moderation.

The Guardian has something called community standards where you find the guidelines for commenting. To be able to comment on the Guardian website you have to register.

In short the Guardian guidelines are:

– If you act with maturity and consideration for other users, you should have no problems.
Don’t be unpleasant. Demonstrate and share the intelligence, wisdom and humour we know you possess.
Take some responsibility for the quality of the conversations in which you’re participating. Help make this an intelligent place for discussion and it will be.

I like the Guardian’s guidelines because they are easy to follow and they are building a good comment community. You want your website to have a pleasant comment environment that can lead to good conversations.

How to moderate your own WordPress blog:

Leave a comment

Filed under Media, Uni

Online News – Convergent journalism

Click on this link if you want an explanation of what convergent journalism is.

Excellence in convergent journalism?

Excellence in convergent journalism is all about speed, accuracy and depth. It can be really hard to fulfil all of these three elements. You usually have to sacrifice at least one of the three when writing online news. The reasons for this is:

  • you’re under time pressure
  • you’re competing against other online publications to publish first
  • you have too many stories to cover because of staff limitation
  • you have too much information organize/go through before writing the story (information overload)

Here is an example of convergent journalism:

In today’s convergent journalism invironment you need comprehensive content. As a journalist this means you need to link to original sources in your story. You have to make it easy for your readers to find more information about the topic you’re writing about by linking or embed content from other websites.

When linking or embedding content you have to think about the strength of the different forms of media.

Creator katerha

Text is still the form of media that is most used online. By using text it’s easy to give the reader context and detail about the topic.

Still photos is also used a lot in online publication, which can make a story more alive and closer to the reader.

Interactive graphics can often give your story that ‘little extra’. Online readers like to interact when they are consuming news content, so using interactive graphics is a good way to keep them interested.

Video is a pretty new form of media in the online environment. However, it’s groving quickly. Video is good for:

  • enhancing the text
  • giving the story a human element
  • giving your source the chance to talk for longer
  • making the focus more about the event the reporter is covering, and not about the reporter
  • flexibility & authenticity

Audio is the form of media that are used the least online. But it could be good for communicating interesting narratives.

Leave a comment

Filed under Media, Uni

Online News – Multimedia Slideshow Pitch

A Day in the Life of Johnno/Pixie Darling

Ella Fisher, Michael Minns and I want to follow Johnno alias Pixie Darling for a day. To see him changing from being Johnno, who works at Bing Lee, to drag queen Pixie Darling.

This is a human interest story. We haven’t really found a very newsworthy angle yet but we’re hoping to get there when we talk to Johnno/Pixie Darling.

Our plan is to capture both pictures and video when we’re out in the field. We definitely want to use colour pictures and video, not black and white shots.

Creator MikeBlogs

For the audio we’re planning to use interviews with Johnno/Pixie Darling and we may use some music if we can get hold of something without copyright issues.

We want to make a fun and exciting multimedia slideshow with lots of colourful pictures, and maybe some video. There are too many boring slidshows out there. We feel like we need to change this, and show the world that slidshows can be funny and entertaining.

Ella and I went to Gender Bender at University of Canberra a few weeks ago where we met Pixie Darling. We knew drag queens were going to attend and preform at Gender Bender but Pixie Darling just blew us away.

When we met her she asked if we had a microphone she could use, so she could interview people walking the red carpet. The red carpet was a blanket next to the door when you walked in. So not very exciting. But when Pixie Darling got a microphone it suddenly turned interesting.

She asked everyone what they were wearing, hit on guys (dressed as girls of course), posed in pictured and just had a blast. The event went from boring to awesome.

Pixie Darling was very open and outspoken, so I think she will be a great talent for our slideshow. I have a good feeling about this.

Pixie Darling on the Red Carpet

Leave a comment

Filed under Media, Uni